Can a Dutch court reduce an agreed penalty?

Yes. Under article 6:94 BW a court may moderate a penalty if fairness manifestly requires it, for example where it is grossly disproportionate to the actual harm.

Do you need to prove actual loss to claim liquidated damages?

No. The whole point of a liquidated-damages clause is to fix the recoverable sum in advance, making proof of loss unnecessary. This is particularly valuable for hard-to-quantify losses such as delayed project completion.

Is there a difference between liquidated damages and a penalty under Dutch law?

Dutch law uses boetebeding for both concepts under BW 6:91-94. A court may moderate a grossly excessive penalty under 6:94, whether it was intended as compensation or punishment.

Can liquidated damages accumulate without a cap?

Yes, unless the contract sets a cap. Without one, daily penalties can accumulate indefinitely until the breach is cured or the contract is terminated. Always negotiate a cap to limit total exposure.

Are liquidated damages common in SaaS contracts?

Less so than in construction. SaaS contracts more commonly use service credits for SLA misses, which serve a similar function but are typically self-executing and much smaller in scale than construction-style liquidated damages.

Liquidated damages

A pre-agreed sum payable on breach, set in advance instead of proving actual loss.

Definição

Liquidated damages are a sum the parties agree in advance will be payable if a specified breach occurs, sparing the need to prove actual loss. In Dutch law this is the boetebeding (penalty clause), recognised in articles 6:91 to 6:94, where the agreed amount can replace or supplement statutory damages. A court may, under article 6:94, moderate a penalty that is manifestly excessive in the circumstances.

Exemplo

A construction contract sets €2,500 per day of late completion as liquidated damages; the client need not prove its exact losses to claim them.

Porque é um risco para a empresa

An uncapped liquidated-damages clause can transform a performance failure into a catastrophic financial liability. Suppliers who sign contracts without checking whether penalties are proportionate to the contract value may find themselves facing claims that dwarf their fee. Customers who set the figure too low may find it is insufficient to cover actual losses and have waived the right to claim the difference.

Como gerir

Cap liquidated damages as a percentage of contract value (e.g. 10-20%) so they remain commercially proportionate.
State whether liquidated damages are the sole remedy for the specified breach or whether the injured party can also claim actual loss above that figure.
Set the daily or weekly rate with reference to the genuine pre-estimate of harm; a rate that is purely punitive may be reduced by a Dutch court.
Track trigger events centrally so you know when a penalty clock has started and can act before it accumulates unduly.

Referências jurídicas

Salvo indicação em contrário, as referências remetem para o direito neerlandês (Burgerlijk Wetboek, o Código Civil neerlandês); os instrumentos da UE, como o RGPD, aplicam-se em toda a UE. Esta é informação geral, não constitui aconselhamento jurídico. Outras jurisdições tratam estes conceitos de forma diferente. Verifique o texto em vigor e a sua situação com um advogado qualificado.

Perguntas frequentes

Questões comuns sobre este termo.